Complete an Online Critique

IMPORTANT: This topic is for Online Critiques only, which is a pilot of new functionality available to a limited subset of reviewers at this time.

Open and Complete the Critique

Follow these steps to complete the online critique:

1. Go to the List of Applications or List of My Assigned Applications screen in Internet Assisted Review (IAR).
2. In the Application Number (Opportunity Number) column for the application for which you are submitting a critique, click the three-dot ellipses icon and select the Submit Critique option.

3. The Online Critique screen opens.

NOTE: Review the Important Reminders heading by clicking on the heading text Important Reminders in the blue bar. This might contain instructions, from the SRO, that are relevant for the current meeting.

4. Click the blue or green headers to expand each section to begin filling out the critique. Use the tab key to jump from field to field.

5. For each review criteria, read the specific guidance for the criteria at the top of the editing area by clicking the read more link.
6. Select scores from the Score dropdown menu.
7. If present, select a radio button from each radio button group.
8. Enter your comments in text fields. See Editing in a Critique Text Field.

TIP: To ensure you do not inadvertently forget a field, enter N/A in the field if you have no comments for the field. This will also reduce warnings about empty fields when you submit the critique.

After you have completed the critique, you are ready to submit the critique; see Submit an Online Critique below. If you don't want to submit at this time, see Save the Critique to Finish Later.

About Scores

NIH and the majority of Operating Divisions (OpDivs) followed the Enhancing Peer Review initiative, characterized by the existence of scored review criteria and a score scale of 1–9. The scored categories differ depending on the Funding Opportunity Announcement (FOA) and activity code of the applications. Reviewers provide separate scores for each category on a scale of 1 to 9, where 1 is exceptional and 9 is poor.

Also see:

• Scoring System and Procedure
• Additional Scoring Guidance for Research Applications
• Additional Scoring Guidance: Applications for Fellowships, Career Awards, and Institutional Training Grants

Online Critique Score Boxes

As NIH transitions to the use of new Online Critique templates, there may be times when reviewers and review staff see a mix of templates in IAR.

Some templates show the criterion/factor score boxes outside of each criterion expandable section.

Newer templates have the score boxes contained within the expandable criterion sections:

To access the score box, expand the section by clicking the section title:

As funding opportunities expire and new opportunities are published, the older templates (score boxes outside the criterion sections) will eventually not be seen.

Editing in a Critique Text Field

When you click in a field, a toolbar appears with formatting tools:

The first six of these are familiar to most users, and are bold, italic, underline, strikethrough, subscript, and superscript. You can hover your cursor over any editing tool to see its name and its keyboard shortcut keys if available.

The less familiar icons are explained below.

Formatting Button	Action
	Removes all formatting from selected text.
	Copy Formatting tool. This works like Microsoft Word's Format Painter tool, transferring formatting from one section of text to another section of text. Select the text with the format you want, then click the Copy Formatting tool, then select the text to which you want to apply formatting.
	Numbered List/Bulleted List tools. Bullet or number the selected text.
	Special character tool. Opens a Select Special Character window, from which you can choose special characters. While you can copy and paste from other applications to the Online Critique screen, special characters might not be rendered correctly in the final critique if you do so. It is recommended that you use the special character editing tool for inserting special characters to ensure correct rendering of special characters.
	Undo and redo tools.